Secret Gardens: Making City Blocks Green to the Core

By Adam Brock

Sometimes Manhattan can feel like an uninterrupted smear of asphalt, stone and concrete. If your daily routine doesn’t happen to take you through a park, the occasional street planting might be the only flora you see on a given day. But that urban wildlife corridor might be closer at hand than you think: a quick Google Earth survey of the city reveals that most blocks are, in fact, donut-shaped, with apartments ringing the street and a substantial chunk of open space in the middle. In most cases, that open space is divided amongst the various buildings on the block, and suffers from poor maintenance and accessibility.

MaDougalGardenBut what if that donut hole wasn’t carved up into dozens of pieces? What if, instead, every city block had a small park at its heart? Besides increasing the amount of urban green space, these “secret gardens” would encourage community cooperation and serve as safe space for children. A precedent, in fact, already exists: the MacDougal-Sullivan garden in Greenwich Village, which has used its donut hole as a common space for decades. An Atlantic Monthly article by William Drayton from back in 2000 (subscription only) described the difference the community green makes in the lives of the block’s residents:

For children the MacDougal-Sullivan garden – which measures about forty by 200 feet and occupies the full interior of the city block – is a private playground; for parents it is a godsend; for busy professionals it is a civilized bit of Europe in the concrete jungle.

Though it’s worthy of emulation, the MacDougal-Sullivan garden is admittedly a special case: it was initiated when the entire block was owned by one person. Carving out communal green space today would be a more complicated process, requiring buy-in from multiple property owners as well as tenants and the even the city government. Drayton’s article suggests legislation modeled on current co-op law, which allows a building to become a cooperative if more than half of the current tenants agree to it.

The most effective catalyst for a comprehensive block greening program, though, is institutional support. The Community Greens initiative, a joint project of the Ashoka Institute and the National Trust for Historic Preservation, is dedicated to promoting the idea of communal green spaces by assisting property owners and governments throughout the country. Baltimore, their first test case, has seen modest success: several alleyways have been cleaned up, gated at either end, and turned into vibrant community spaces.

Of course, every city has a completely different set of conditions affecting the creation of communal green space, and what works for Baltimore probably won’t make sense in the Five Boroughs. But with a context-sensitive approach and the proper support, Community Greens might just be the answer to turning that backyard junk pile into a thriving private park.


One thought on “Secret Gardens: Making City Blocks Green to the Core

  1. Bennett says:

    I went to a party on Ten Eyck street in Brooklyn in a recently developed building that had a nice example of a communal space out back:,-95.677068&sspn=35.273162,67.236328&ie=UTF8&ll=40.70992,-73.949897&spn=0.001031,0.002052&t=k&z=19&om=1
    Its not the whole block, but the developer must have bought two lots that backed up against one another and decided to make it public. All the ground floor apartments had doors that let out on the backyard, and I think the upper floors on each building might have access through the stairwells. You can see the ample lawn, there is also a patio, a kind of rock statue/garden, and I think there was a flower garden as well. It seemed like a great place to socialize with what looked like a mostly young population of tenants. When I got there, a band was just packing up their gear – apparently people play shows out there pretty often. It made a lot more sense than trying to divide up the space into little lots for each apartment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s